May 23, 2025
By Rehan Piracha
LAHORE: It has been 10 years since Ihsanullah disappeared. It is believed that he was detained by law enforcement agencies, even though the boy was only 13 years old at the time of his disappearance in September 2015. Now 10 agonizing years later, his family has sought help from the Peshawer High Court.
The case throws a light onto Pakistan’s unresolved crisis of enforced disappearances.
Recently the PHC issued notices to the federal and provincial governments (Khyber Pukhtunkhwa) after a petition was filed by Ihsanullah’s father Sarfaraz Khan. The bench headed by Chief Justice S.M Atiq Shah directed authorities to submit a report on the boy’s whereabouts, but for Khan, the legal battle is just one more step in a decade-long struggle for answers.
A family’s ordeal
According to the petition, Ihsanullah had been taken into custody along with his father and brother during a raid in Peshawar’s Pauka locality. The operation had involved the local police, Counter Terrorism Department (CTD) officials, and military personnel, while the family’s property documents, car, and mobile phones were also seized. While Khan and his other son were eventually released, Ihsanullah remained in custody.
“They (officials) had assured us that he would be freed after questioning,” Khan states in his petition. “But ten years have passed, and we still don’t know if he’s alive or dead.”
Hanif Afridi, the family lawyer, told Voicepk, that despite repeated pleas to the KP Chief Minister’s Complaint Cell, the Peshawar police chief, and the CTD’s deputy inspector general, no action has been taken. The family’s desperation has now forced them to approach the high court—a last resort after years of bureaucratic silence.
Disturbingly, Khan claims he still receives occasional calls from law enforcement officials asking whether his son has returned home. “It’s torture,” Afridi said. “They know where he is, but no one is willing to give us answers.”
A systemic crisis
Ihsanullah’s case is far from isolated. According to the Commission of Inquiry on Enforced Disappearances (COIED), a state-appointed body tasked with investigating such cases, 1,941 reported disappearances remain unresolved as of April 2025.
The data reveals a grim regional disparity: KP: 1,286 pending cases; Balochistan (217); Punjab (248); Sindh (129); Islamabad (49); and Azad Jammu & Kashmir: (12).
KP’s disproportionately high numbers underscore the lingering impact of counterterrorism operations and militancy in the region. Yet, despite the commission’s mandate, families of the missing accuse it of inefficacy. Notably, Khan never registered his son’s case with the COIED—a common refrain among disillusioned relatives who see the body as powerless.
Enforced disappearances have plagued Pakistan for decades, with activists blaming intelligence agencies, police, and paramilitary forces for unlawful detentions, particularly in conflict zones like KP and Balochistan. While authorities often deny involvement, victims’ families insist their loved ones were taken into custody—only to vanish into a legal black hole.
Rights groups argue that Pakistan’s judicial and administrative systems lack the will—or the ability—to hold perpetrators accountable. Activists say families are left in limbo, with no closure, and no justice. For Sarfraz Khan, the court’s notice is a flicker of hope—but after ten years of silence, justice remains elusive.
