Voicepk.netVoicepk.netVoicepk.net
Font ResizerAa
  • News
    • National
    • Punjab
    • Sindh
    • Khyber Pakhtunkhwa
    • Federal Territory
    • Gilgit-Baltistan
    • Balochistan
    • Azad Jammu Kashmir
    • World
  • Exclusive Shows
    • Frontline Pakistan
    • Rights Watch
  • In Focus
    • Opinion
    • Features
    • Webinars
  • Climate Watch
  • Exclusives
    • Documentaries
    • Rights Guide
  • Events
    • AJCONF
    • Other
  • About Us
    • AGHS Legal Aid Cell
    • Our Team
    • Contact
  • اردو ویب سائٹ
Reading: Caste is the missing piece in Pakistan’s minority quotas: CLJ report
Share
Font ResizerAa
Voicepk.netVoicepk.net
  • News
  • Exclusive Shows
  • In Focus
  • Climate Watch
  • Exclusives
  • Events
  • About Us
  • اردو ویب سائٹ
Search here....
  • News
    • National
    • Punjab
    • Sindh
    • Khyber Pakhtunkhwa
    • Federal Territory
    • Gilgit-Baltistan
    • Balochistan
    • Azad Jammu Kashmir
    • World
  • Exclusive Shows
    • Frontline Pakistan
    • Rights Watch
  • In Focus
    • Opinion
    • Features
    • Webinars
  • Climate Watch
  • Exclusives
    • Documentaries
    • Rights Guide
  • Events
    • AJCONF
    • Other
  • About Us
    • AGHS Legal Aid Cell
    • Our Team
    • Contact
  • اردو ویب سائٹ
Follow US
NationalNEWS

Caste is the missing piece in Pakistan’s minority quotas: CLJ report

9 Min Read

November 21, 2026

By Rehan Piracha


LAHORE

The Center for Law and Justice (CLJ) has released a policy report urging Pakistan and the European Union to treat caste as a named, measurable form of exclusion in Pakistan’s bid to keep its GSP+ trade status. Naming Caste in Pakistan, by Asif Angelo Aqeel and Mary James Gill, proposes fifteen steps: eight for Islamabad and seven for Brussels.

Seeing the minority within the minority

The report argues that treating all non-Muslims as one bloc hides who is worst off. It introduces “Caste-Marginalised Religious Minorities” (CMRMs): communities marked by outcaste descent, minority religion and stigmatised, sometimes bonded, work. In practice these are Christians, most of them descended from Chuhra sweeper castes, and Scheduled Caste Hindus. The authors call the concept “a lens for measurement, not a new legal category.”

What CLJ wants Pakistan to do

The report singles out four priority commitments for Pakistan’s GSP+ plan of action. Firstly,  ending recruitment that reserves sanitation work for non-Muslims. Secondly,  publishing minority employment data by grade and occupation, not only by religion. Thirdly,  bringing sanitation, kiln and farm labour into labour-inspection priorities while recording religion in the planned Forced Labour Survey. Lastly, reporting on caste to the UN committees on racial and gender discrimination.

The full list begins with a comprehensive anti-discrimination law that names caste and descent, restoring in statute the ban on untouchability in the 1956 Constitution. It also asks for a dedicated law for waste and sanitation workers, modelled on the Punjab bill introduced in September 2026. That law would bar sewer entry without protective equipment, gas testing and rescue cover, and would mechanise sewer cleaning within five years while retraining workers as operators. The same protections would extend to bonded labourers in kilns and farms. The report also asks the National Commission for Minorities Rights to monitor the quota by descent.

The most contentious proposal is a reserved CMRM share. It would cover three of the five percentage points of the minority job quota, three-fifths of minority education places and welfare schemes, and a proportionate share of reserved legislative seats. The share is provisional and would be reviewed within three years. Eligibility would be by descent and on a person’s own application, through a certificate that “names no caste.” A mobility programme of skills training, school retention and upgraded sanitation colonies would be open to anyone by descent or occupation, whatever their religion.

What it asks of the EU

For Brussels, CLJ wants caste, descent and sanitation workers named in GSP+ assessments, and Pakistan’s eight steps treated as dated benchmarks in its plan of action. It asks the EU to report on them every three-year cycle, hear affected communities on monitoring visits, and count who EU-funded programmes reach. The authors “strongly support” Pakistan’s reapplication, calling GSP+ the “strongest leverage available.” They ask for benchmarks, not penalties.

Protection built for outcastes, reassigned to all

The authors argue that Pakistan began with caste-aware protections. Punjab reserved five per cent of posts jointly for Christians and Scheduled Castes in 1942, and a six per cent federal Scheduled Caste quota followed in 1948. The 1956 Constitution banned untouchability, and a 1957 Ordinance scheduled forty communities. The federal quota was withdrawn in 1996, and the 2009 replacement is open to all non-Muslims. In 1943 Jinnah said he cared “more for [the untouchables] than for Mussalmans.”

Their argument is that a remedy designed for descent became a quota by religion. They say it cannot tell a Zoroastrian businessman from a sewer worker, and so can look successful while the intended beneficiaries stay where they were.

Sweepers by the hundreds, officers by the handful

The report’s figures show how sharply employment divides along religious and caste lines. At the University of the Punjab, 396 of 400 sanitation workers are Christian, while about one of roughly 900 faculty members is non-Muslim. The same pattern runs through public bodies, from the Water and Sanitation Agency in Lahore to the federal civil service, where non-Muslims fill the lowest grades but are almost absent from the highest. These are the report’s main findings:

Concentration: At the University of the Punjab, 396 of 400 sanitation workers are Christian, against roughly one non-Muslim among about 900 faculty. Christians hold 99 per cent of sanitation posts in the lowest pay grade but under five per cent of messenger posts. The authors say qualifications cannot explain this.

Lowest grades: The National Commission for Human Rights found 80 per cent of non-Muslim government employees in grades 1 to 4. The federal bulletin for 2021–22 shows 249 of 19,128 non-Muslim employees, or 1.3 per cent, in grades 17 to 22.

Empty quota posts: Of 655 minority-quota posts at the Punjab Public Service Commission between January 2025 and July 2026, 500 stayed vacant. The official explanation, as in 1957, is the “non-availability of qualified candidates.”

Explicit discrimination: CLJ collected 281 government advertisements from 2010 to March 2025 reserving sanitation posts for non-Muslims, at least 16 of them after the Supreme Court’s 2022 direction to avoid such advertising.

Deaths: Twenty-six sanitation workers died in sewers in the eight months to September 2026, and, as Dawn noted, none was Muslim. The Lahore Waste Management Company told CLJ that all 9,000 of its waste workers were non-Muslim.

Bondage: About three million people are estimated to be in debt bondage, yet Pakistan has no national survey. The report says that outside sanitation, official data on the religion or caste of workers in these sectors do not exist.

The authors also cite the UN Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination (CERD), which in 2024 voiced concern at “persistent racial discrimination, in particular caste-based discrimination.” It singled out job advertisements targeting non-Muslims for sanitation work. The report adds that the European Commission’s 2026 assessment found the quota confined to “lower-grade, manual, or hazardous jobs” but did not name the communities concerned. The 2023 assessment had said sanitation work was “primarily conducted by minorities.”

Why now

GSP+ gave Pakistan €7.5 billion in eligible exports to the EU in 2024 and an estimated €732 million in tariff exemptions. Under Regulation (EU) 2026/1395, applicable from 1 January 2027, Pakistan must submit a new request with a plan of action by 31 December 2028. Its next CERD report is due on 4 January 2028. The authors say most of their steps simply meet obligations Pakistan has already accepted. They add that the steps do not require repealing blasphemy laws or amending the Constitution.

The report proposes three stages. Administrative steps would be in place by the end of 2028, laws in force between 2029 and 2031, and mechanisation and a census question on caste by 2036. Its summary of the argument: “Without a name there can be no data.”

CLJ says plainly that it is “not a neutral observer” and that it drafted the Punjab bill. The report does not cost its steps or assess their political feasibility. It says the evidence is strongest for sanitation and public employment in Punjab, and thinner elsewhere. The proposed share rests partly on one scholar’s estimate that 90 to 95 per cent of Pakistani Christians are of Dalit descent. The report also lists unresolved legal questions, including whether the share needs an Act of Parliament and whether it is consistent with Articles 25, 27 and 36 of the Constitution.

 

LHC orders ministries to ensure submission of replies in Sarabjeet Kaur case
LARKANA: Widow and daughter killed after ‘food not served on time’
Journalist Farhan Mallick accused of spoofing, remanded in second cybercrime case
Shrine custodian apologises after attack on Badin Press Club
Peshawar High Court (PHC) seeks report from Kohat police over missing computer science lecturer
Share This Article
Facebook Email Print

Follow Us

OUR SOCIALS
Facebook Twitter Instagram Youtube Tiktok Whatsapp

Journalism for Human Rights in Pakistan

Voicepk.net

About Us

Voicepk.net is Pakistan ‘s first digital media platform dedicated to investigating, reporting & broadcasting human rights and legal issues happening in the country.
Read More...

Quick Link
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Our Team
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
© 2026. All Rights Reserved by VoicePk.net
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Username or Email Address
Password

Lost your password?