October 28, 2026
By Ahmed Saeed
LAHORE
The Lahore High Court has acquitted a woman serving a life sentence for murdering her husband after lawyers from the AGHS Legal Aid Cell took up her case during a visit to Faisalabad jail. The case highlights the role of prison outreach programmes in providing legal representation to prisoners who cannot afford a lawyer.
Justice Muhammad Amjad Rafiq accepted Safia Akram’s appeal, set aside her conviction and ordered her release, ruling that the prosecution had failed to prove her involvement in the murder beyond reasonable doubt.
The AGHS Legal Aid Cell’s jail visits programme involves visits to prisons across Punjab to identify undertrial and convicted prisoners in need of free legal assistance, particularly women, children and members of religious minorities and other marginalised communities.
According to Rubina Shaheen, women’s protection officer at AGHS, Safia’s case was taken up during a visit to a jail in Faisalabad. She said the programme had been running since the early 1980s and had provided free legal assistance to thousands of people from marginalised communities.
“Since 2021, 1,890 people have been provided legal aid, and bail petitions have been filed on their behalf. All these cases were identified through jail visits,” Shaheen said.
She added that AGHS had also filed 209 petitions challenging convictions since 2021. Of these, the convictions of 55 people had been overturned and they had been released since 2025.
In a judgment in the Safia Akram case, the high court also dismissed a criminal revision petition filed by complainant Muhammad Siddique, who had sought an enhancement of Safia’s sentence.
Safia was convicted by an additional sessions judge in Kamalia on June 13, 2024, under Section 302(b) of the Pakistan Penal Code and sentenced to life imprisonment as ta’zir. She was also ordered to pay Rs300,000 in compensation to the deceased’s legal heirs, with six months of additional imprisonment in case of default.
The case originated from an incident on the night of July 13, 2022, when two unidentified men allegedly entered the house of Safia and her husband, Fazal Usman, in Kamalia, Toba Tek Singh district. According to the prosecution, the men took Usman to a room, where he was beaten, attacked with a knife, and set on fire. He was shifted to hospitals in Shorkot and Multan and died on July 20, 2022.
The FIR, registered at Saddar police station in Kamalia, did not nominate Safia as an accused. She was implicated through a supplementary statement recorded on July 21, a day after her husband’s death.
In its judgment, the high court identified several inconsistencies in the prosecution’s case, including the delay in reporting the incident, contradictory accounts of an alleged extra-judicial confession, doubts about the statements of the couple’s children and questions surrounding the recovery of an alleged murder weapon.
The court held that medical evidence could establish the nature and manner of the injuries but could not independently identify the person responsible for the murder.
“Medical evidence is essentially corroborative in character; it may confirm the nature, seat and manner of injuries but ordinarily cannot, by itself, establish the identity of the assailant,” the judgment stated.
It added that medical evidence could not compensate for weaknesses in the prosecution’s account of Safia’s alleged involvement in the crime.
The court also questioned the recovery of a hammer from Safia’s room on July 30, 2022, which the prosecution presented as incriminating evidence. It noted that police had already inspected the same room on July 15, raising doubts about why they had not discovered the alleged weapon earlier.
The judgment observed that the recovery of a weapon was corroborative in nature and could not independently sustain a conviction without reliable evidence connecting the accused to the offence.
The court was also critical of the prosecution’s changing account of the incident. It noted that the FIR initially referred to two unidentified assailants, while Safia was subsequently nominated without tangible and independent incriminating evidence.
The judgment described the subsequent changes in the prosecution’s version as “a conspicuous attempt to transfer the burden of the crime onto her.”
It also noted that Usman survived for approximately six days after the attack, observing that the conduct attributed to Safia did not sit comfortably with the prosecution’s allegation of an intention to commit intentional murder and, at the very least, created reasonable doubt.
Extending the benefit of doubt to Safia, the court reiterated that an accused person was entitled to acquittal where the prosecution failed to establish guilt beyond reasonable doubt.
Safia was represented by Shabbir Hussain, a Supreme Court advocate and senior associate of the AGHS Legal Aid Cell.
Established by lawyer Asma Jahangir, AGHS has provided legal assistance to women, children and other marginalised groups, including people facing criminal charges and those seeking relief against wrongful convictions. Its jail visits programme serves as a means of identifying prisoners who may otherwise lack access to legal representation
