June 15, 2026
By Ahmed Saeed
LAHORE
The Peshawar High Court Abbottabad Bench has ruled that constitutional protections of privacy, dignity and personal liberty cannot be set aside through arbitrary police action in cases involving alleged immorality, holding that raids on private residences without a search warrant amount to unlawful intrusion prohibited by law.
A single member bench of Justice Syed Mudasser Ameer of the Abbottabad Bench issued the ruling while granting bail to three individuals — Noor Muhammad, Mst. Asima Bibi and Mst. Madiha Bibi — who were arrested on May 2, 2026 by officials of City Police Station Mansehra following a raid on a private rented house at Tanki Mor, Mansehra.
The three were charged under sections 371-A and 371-B of the Pakistan Penal Code, which deal with the selling and buying of persons for the purpose of prostitution. One other individual present at the premises escaped during the raid.
Incorrect sections invoked
In a five-page order, the court held that the charges invoked against the petitioners bore no legal basis on the facts as presented. According to the FIR, police received a public complaint alleging that the house was being used for prostitution and conducted a raid, finding a male and a female present in one of the rooms, whereas another male and female in another room. One male suspect present at the premises escaped during the raid.
The court noted, however, that the FIR contained no allegation that any person had been bought, sold, trafficked, hired or commercially exploited for purposes of prostitution. No money was recovered, no customer was found negotiating any transaction, and no material indicative of organised prostitution or trafficking was secured during the raid.
“Sections 371-A and 371-B PPC are intended to curb trafficking, sale, purchase and commercial exploitation of human beings for purposes of prostitution,” the court stated. “Mere allegation of immoral conduct or mere presence of a male and female inside a private premises does not ipso facto attract the said provisions unless material exists showing buying, selling, hiring, trafficking or commercial sexual exploitation of a person.”
The court further held that even if a man and woman were found together in an objectionable condition inside a private house, this alone was not sufficient to attract the said provisions. “At best, the allegations merely suggest presence of opposite genders inside a private house. Such circumstance by itself does not constitute the offences alleged”, the court noted
The court added that “where allegations merely relate to consensual intercourse or fornication, prosecution, if any could only proceed through complaint under section 203-C Cr.P.C. and not through registration of FIR under sections 371-A and 371-B PPC.”
Constitutional concerns over raid
Beyond the question of the charges, the court expressed serious concern over the manner in which the police had conducted the operation.
“The manner in which the raid was conducted also raises serious legal and constitutional concerns. Admittedly, the raid was carried out at a private dwelling house without obtaining any search warrant from a Magistrate and without associating respectable persons of the locality. Such intrusion into a private home, particularly involving arrest of women, directly touches upon the constitutional guarantees relating to dignity of man, privacy of home and liberty protected under Articles 4, 9 and 14 of the Constitution”, the order said.
Referring to a series of earlier judgments of superior courts, the bench observed that courts had repeatedly cautioned against the use of immorality-related offences as a pretext for unconstitutional police action. “Under the garb of offences relating to prostitution and immorality, constitutional protections available to citizens cannot be permitted to be violated through arbitrary police action founded merely upon suspicion, anonymous complaints or spy information,” the court stated.
The court further noted that no police official should be granted immunity for degrading the dignity and reputation of citizens through unlawful intrusion into private life.
