May 18, 2027
By Rehan Piracha
JACOBABAD
More than a week has passed since violence erupted in the village of Muhammad Siddiq Arain in Thal tehsil of Jacobabad district over a love marriage dispute, yet tension in the area remains high. Families rendered homeless after a frenzied mob torched their homes continue to endure scorching heat under open skies, while police have tightened security by establishing pickets across the village. The Sindh government, meanwhile, has announced relief for the victims.
How it all began
According to police, Sidra Channa and Muhammad Hassan Burro left their homes on May 4 and the following day, May 5, solemnised a court marriage of their own free will in Hyderabad. As soon as the video of the wedding went viral on social media, an enraged mob descended on Muhammad Siddiq Arain — the village of the Burro community — and set homes ablaze. There have been reports of between 100 houses being reduced to ashes in the attack, while the victims’ lawyer, Nissar Ahmed Maghiari, claims the number of burnt houses exceeds 120.
Scores of families have been left to fend for themselves under the open sky. The affected residents say their homes were set on fire without any justification and that everything they owned has been turned to cinders. They are demanding justice, compensation for their losses, reconstruction of their homes, and adequate protection for their safety.
Police conducting raids to arrest suspects: SSP
SSP Jacobabad Faizan Ali said that police intervened in time to prevent the situation from deteriorating further. So far, five suspects have been arrested in connection with the incident, while several others remain at large — some of whom managed to obtain bail even before their arrest. Police have registered two separate cases: one concerning the alleged abduction of the girl and the other under the provisions of the Anti-Terrorism Act relating to the burning of the village. The cases name 12 identified suspects along with 20 unidentified individuals. A special investigation team has also been constituted under the supervision of DSP Thal to take the probe forward.
Survey of burnt houses completed: Govt spokesperson
The Chief Minister of Sindh has taken notice of the incident. Speaking with Voicepk by phone from Karachi on Monday, government spokesperson Sadia Javed said the administration had acted on the matter from the very first day and that steps would be taken to compensate for the damage caused to affected homes.
“The Sindh chief minister has directed the deputy commissioner and the divisional commissioner to carry out a survey of the burnt houses so that requisite assistance could be provided to the victims who lost their homes in the violence,” Sadia Javed said, adding that the assistant commissioner had completed the survey and would likely forward it to the deputy commissioner.
She said the MPA and MNA of the area were both elected from the PPP and that it was the responsibility of the government not to abandon people who had reposed their trust in the PPP government.
Sadia Javed said the provincial government was not taking sides in the case and that authorities were looking into the role of the influential rival feudal landlords who are said to have played a part in fomenting the violence.
She confirmed that Sidra Chana is safe and in government custody, and that the matter is before the courts. “There were three cases — the protection sought by the man who contracted the love marriage, the burning of houses, and lastly the application by the girl’s father claiming his daughter is 14 years old and therefore underage under the Child Marriage Restraint Act — that the courts heard today.”
The court will determine whether the girl is underage or not, she added. The government has also directed the relevant authorities to take immediate action against those responsible. “The situation remains under control and normalcy has returned,” she told Voicepk.
A tangle of contradictory claims
The accounts offered by the different parties stand in sharp contradiction to one another.
The girl’s father, Rafiq Channa, firmly rejected allegations that his community burnt the village and claimed that his two daughters were abducted at gunpoint in the dead of night. He argued that since Sidra is only 14 years old and his other daughter, Aqsa, is just four, the question of a consensual marriage involving a minor simply does not arise. He went so far as to allege that the opposing party had set fire to their own homes in order to file a false case against him and his community.
However in a video message, Sidra Channa, said that she was an adult and had married entirely of her own free will. Muhammad Hassan Burro, for his part, appealed to the government to ensure the protection of their lives and property, saying that their village had been burned down and that they continued to face serious threats.
Influential landlords left out of FIR, claims lawyer
The victims’ lawyer, Nissar Ahmed Maghiari, has alleged that two influential tribal chieftains affiliated with the ruling party — Sardar Saddam Hussain Burro and Sardar Ahmed Ali Chana — were the driving force behind the attack, yet police failed to name them in the case. According to the lawyer, an application has been filed before the Anti-Terrorism Court to have their names included. He further revealed that on May 10, the same two sardars allegedly returned to the village and threatened residents with death, prompting a separate petition to be filed before the District and Sessions Court under Section 22-A(b).
Sardar Saddam Hussain Burro, however, dismissed all allegations against him as entirely baseless, insisting that he had gone to the site on May 5 solely to defuse the situation. Sardar Ahmed Ali Chana has not made any public statement regarding his role in the dispute. This incident once again lays bare the deep-rooted social prejudices against love marriages in Sindh’s tribal and rural areas, as well as the unchecked influence wielded by powerful sardars. Meanwhile, the displaced families continue to wait — for justice, and for a roof over their heads.
Women’s Action Forum condemns
The Women’s Action Forum strongly condemned the act of targeting a couple in Jacobabad on the basis of marriage of choice and then setting fire to the entire village.
This incident is not only an injustice against an individual or a family, but an attack on the entire society, law and human dignity, said their press release. “This is the worst example of failure of state, governance and society at the same time. During the rule of almost 18 years, instead of social reforms and long-term policies, the PPP has thrown Upper Sindh at the mercy of feudal lords, a tribal system and so-called honour.
As a result, there is no fear of law, nor fear of punishment by state institutions. Every party is showing brutality by breaking the legal and moral boundaries to crush the weak. Today there is no such thing as fear of law in Sindh, due to which such barbaric acts are being carried out with great shamelessness and fearlessness.
It is also a degradation of social ethics to burn the entire village in exchange of a couple’s choice of marriage or personal decision. This failure of all institutions of the state is a very dangerous example. When rulers back down power and the state remains silent, criminals become more powerful. At present, the rulers of Sindh are so intoxicated with their power that they do not care about the lives of women, nor about the homes and honor of poor people.
Women are particularly targeted in this worst governance. Almost 178 women have been killed in the name of false honour in just one month, but the government has completely failed to stop these incidents, punish the perpetrators or provide protection to women.
In Sindh, violence against women, coercive decisions, impeachment, jirgas and tribal terrorism have become the norm, while the rulers are limited to statements and demonstrative actions.
We want to make it clear that acts like honor killing, humiliation of women, burning people alive and setting fire to villages are not related to any civilization, religion or tradition, but they are pure crimes, which are supported by political patronage and state weakness.”
WAF has demanded that all the accused involved in the Jacobabad incident should be immediately arrested and punished severely, protection, financial assistance and full justice should be provided to the affected families, a complete ban on honor killings, jirgans and tribal decisions should be imposed in Sindh, legal and administrative steps should be taken on an emergency basis to prevent violence against women, and the state should take clear and practical action against bigotry, feudal and tribal terrorism and restore the rule of law.
WAF members said that if the state continues to remain silent, Sindh would end up suffering more violence, fear and misogyny.
