April 10, 2026
By Rehan Piracha
LAHORE
As India and Pakistan navigate the aftermath of Operation Sindoor and the wider turbulence of the US–Iran conflict, peace activists, scholars and feminist voices from both countries gathered virtually on Friday said war has no winners, and the people who pay the highest price are never those who order it.
The Pakistan India Peoples’ Forum for Peace and Democracy (PIPFPD) hosted the webinar titled “Counting the Cost of Conflicts: Why Peace Matters” on April 10, bringing together six speakers from India and Pakistan alongside PIPFPD’s leadership. The event was moderated by Rita Manchanda, a founding member of the forum, and opened by Syeda Hameed, chairperson of PIPFPD’s India chapter.
‘Operation Sindoor is just a pause’
Opening the discussion, Manchanda noted that recent cultural productions—such as the film Dhurandar—had helped normalise the idea of war between India and Pakistan, while civil society in both countries continued to reject the narrative of hostility promoted by their respective governments on the international stage. She described the recent peace between South Asian neighbours was precarious, warning that “Operation Sindoor is just a pause between India and Pakistan.”
Manchanda also expressed regret over India’s muted response to Pakistan’s emerging role as a mediator between Iran and the United States, noting that Pakistan shares a 900-kilometre border with Iran and has a direct stake in regional peace. She asked speakers to reflect on what lessons the Iran–US conflict might hold for India and Pakistan.
‘Wars are felt emotionally, not rationally’
Scholar and policy analyst Saba Gul Khattak spoke with raw emotion about the human cost of conflict. “War is not something I can speak about without emotion,” she said. “Recent wars are like video games—you click a button and you wreck a house and families.” She described the lasting anguish of parents who had lost children to school bombings over decades, arguing that infrastructure could eventually be rebuilt but that the pain of bereaved families never would be.
Khattak lamented the collapse of faith in international law, pointing to the destruction of schools and health infrastructure with what she called “impunity.” She also criticised the one-sided media coverage that wars generate, noting that audiences self-select channels that reinforce their own positions. “There are no winners, and the poor always suffer,” she said, adding that the Pakistan–Afghanistan conflict had been further overshadowed by the US–Iran confrontation.
Feminism, militarism and the war on people
Filmmaker and women’s rights activist Vani Subramaniam linked the politics of militarisation to the surge of nationalism and chauvinism across the world. “National fervour and jingoism have a certain way of mobilising everybody,” she observed, noting that over the past decade, this sentiment in India had served to shore up the government’s position. Those who refused to follow the current of nationalist feeling, she warned, became targets. “The war on terror,” she said, “has been launched on the people of both nations.” She called for peace and democracy to be framed explicitly as a feminist demand across borders.
Gender rights activist Tahira Abdullah echoed this concern about the systematic exclusion of women from peace processes. “Where are the women? Why are women absent from forums of peace?” she asked, pointing to their absence from peace talks and negotiations in Afghanistan, Pakistan and other conflict zones around the world. She cited the Iranian women’s movement as an example of how feminism and national solidarity need not be contradictory: “Iranian women have shown you can be a feminist, but when you are under attack from an imperialist force like the US, you can stand up with unity for your country.”
Abdullah also raised a pointed question about education: “The textbooks are of hate, not peace—what are we teaching in schools if we want to build peace between India and Pakistan?” She called for the reactivation of government-to-government channels under SAFMA and SAFTA, and drew attention to Pakistan’s role—alongside China, Turkey and Egypt—in the US–Iran mediation, quoting economist Atif Mian’s estimate that the mediation made the world significantly wealthier.
Economic rights and people’s solidarity
Author and economic rights activist Navsharan Singh characterised the current moment as one of deep injustice for ordinary people. She described the US–Iran conflict as “a war of plunder,” warning that South Asians working in Gulf countries had been dragged into a conflict not of their making, with their futures placed at risk. She criticised India’s failure to rescue the crew of an Iranian warship sunk by a US torpedo, calling the incident a tragedy that illustrated the human consequences of geopolitical conflict.
Singh also highlighted acts of cross-border solidarity that rarely surface in mainstream media. She noted that farmers’ unions in India had held protests during Operation Sindoor, insisting that war was not the answer and calling for peace with Pakistan. Hundreds of activists from both countries had signed a joint statement demanding de-escalation. She recalled that people in the Indian Punjab had appreciated Pakistan for opening barrage gates during floods the previous year—an act of quiet goodwill that went largely unreported.
KP, Balochistan and the forgotten wars within
Former ombudsperson and activist Rukhshanda Naz brought attention to the compounded crises facing Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, where internally displaced persons in Tirah and communities uprooted by the Pakistan–Afghanistan border conflict were already struggling before the US–Iran war began. She described the people of KP as having been “used as fuel” in the US war in Afghanistan. Citing figures that suggested more lives had been lost in Balochistan and KP over forty years than in Afghanistan, she argued that the Pakistani government should channel its resources into youth development in these conflict-ridden regions rather than continued military operations.
Naz also raised the challenge of engaging the younger generation, warning that youth on both sides of the India–Pakistan border were increasingly preoccupied with social media propaganda and had little appetite for listening to feminist and peace voices. “We need to think about how to increase youth participation on both sides of the Indo-Pak border to build peace initiatives,” she said.
Chairing the session, Syeda Hameed paid tribute to towering figures in the peace movement, including Asma Jahangir, IA Rehman and Tapan Bose, saying they “played an important part in peace.” She expressed the forum’s earnest hope of holding a joint PIPFPD convention in both India and Pakistan this year, and recited Urdu couplets to illustrate the role of poets in illuminating the path to peace and democracy.
Tahira Abdullah recalled a touching moment from the forum’s tenth joint convention, when Amit Chakravorty’s six-year-old son observed of the Pakistani guests: “They are like us.” “These are small words,” said Abdullah, “but they carry great depth.” She lamented that while the forum’s first decade had been intensely active, the second and third decades had seen it struggle to convene, and urged all sides to redouble their efforts.
Looking ahead, PIPFPD’s India chapter announced it would organise a national convention on April 18–19 titled “Ishq, Siyasat aur Awam: Why Peace Matters,” bringing together political dialogue and cultural expression. The event will explore themes of peace, anti-war politics and human rights through the works of poets Paash, Sahir Ludhianvi and Faiz Ahmed Faiz. At a time when militarised nationalism continues to shape public discourse, the forum insists that dialogue and solidarity across borders are not a luxury—they are a necessity.
