January 11, 2025
By Rana Malhi
ISLAMABAD
In an important meeting of the Judicial Commission of Pakistan held on Monday, several key constitutional, institutional, and policy matters relating to the higher judiciary were discussed and decisions were taken regarding the confirmation of additional judges of the Islamabad High Court and the Balochistan High Court.
According to a statement issued by the Supreme Court of Pakistan, the meetings of the Judicial Commission were convened under various constitutional configurations and were chaired by the Chief Justice of Pakistan in his capacity as Chairman of the Judicial Commission.
The meeting held detailed deliberations on judicial appointments, the establishment of constitutional benches, the procedure for judicial interviews, and amendments to relevant laws.
Recommended judges to become permanent
The statement said that, by majority vote, the Judicial Commission recommended the confirmation of three additional judges of the Islamabad High Court as permanent judges. The judges recommended for confirmation are Justice Muhammad Azam Khan, Justice Muhammad Asif, and Justice Inam Amin Minhas. Before making these recommendations, the Commission conducted a thorough review of the judges’ data forms, past judicial records, service profiles, and other relevant material.
Similarly, the Judicial Commission unanimously approved the appointment of Justice Najamuddin Mengal as a permanent judge of the Balochistan High Court. However, by majority vote, the Commission rejected the recommendation for confirmation of Additional Judge Justice Ayub Khan of the Balochistan High Court. The statement noted that this decision was also taken strictly in accordance with constitutional and legal requirements.
In addition to matters of judicial confirmation, the Judicial Commission also held detailed discussions on important policy issues related to the judicial system. Under Article 175A(2) of the Constitution, the Core Commission consulted on the criteria for the nomination of judges to constitutional benches in the high courts. The meeting emphasized that the establishment of constitutional benches and the nomination of judges for them must be transparent and based on merit.
According to the statement, the procedure for interviews of candidates for judicial appointments was also discussed in detail. In addition, proposed amendments to the Judicial Commission of Pakistan (Appointment of Judges) Rules, 2024 were considered, particularly those related to appointments to the Federal Constitutional Court.
Committee formed
The Judicial Commission has authorized a committee to conduct a more detailed review of all these matters.
The committee has been directed to prepare comprehensive recommendations on the interview procedure, criteria for constitutional benches, and the proposed amendments to the rules, and to present them before the Commission.
According to the statement, the purpose of the committee’s recommendations is to ensure transparency in the judicial system and the effective implementation of the constitutional framework.
The statement said that the Judicial Commission considers such measures essential for strengthening the judicial system, promoting institutional reforms, and maintaining public confidence.
The process of appointment and confirmation of judges in the higher judiciary is not only a constitutional responsibility but also a fundamental pillar of the justice delivery system.
The role of the Judicial Commission of Pakistan holds central importance in the appointment, confirmation, and policymaking related to judges in the higher judiciary, and its decisions have far-reaching effects on the country’s judicial system. The decisions taken in the meeting will now proceed through the final stages of approval in accordance with the constitutional procedure.
