January 23, 2025
By Rehan Piracha and Ahmed Saeed
LAHORE
The federal government of Pakistan has appointed former Supreme Court judge Faqeer Muhammad Khokhar as the new head of the Commission of Inquiry on Enforced Disappearances (COIED). He succeeds retired Supreme Court judge Javed Iqbal, who led the commission since its inception in 2011.
The COIED was established in 2011 to trace missing persons and hold perpetrators accountable for enforced disappearances. However, the commission has faced persistent criticism from human rights organizations and activists for its ineffectiveness and lack of accountability.
A legacy of failure
Over the years, the COIED has been widely criticized for failing to fulfill its mandate. Rights groups have documented thousands of cases of enforced disappearances, particularly in Balochistan and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, often linked to security operations. Despite receiving new complaints and resolving cases annually—including 379 new complaints and 427 resolved cases in 2024—the commission had 2,251 pending cases as of December 31, 2024.
‘Elderly Khokhar does not bode well’
Nasrullah Baloch, chairperson of the Voice for Baloch Missing Persons (VBMP), an organisation working with families of missing persons in Balochistan, has been fiercely vocal about the new appointment. Already dissatisfied with the performance of the commission, he criticised the government for appointing an octogenarian to the post.
“The government’s decision is wrong given that Khokhar is over 80 years old and he might face health problems which would not bode well for working of the commission,” he told Voicepk. He said the performance of the commission had not been stellar since its formation 14 years ago. “The commission had not taken measures to either resolve the issue of enforced disappearances or hold officials accountable over it,” he added.
Baloch said the families of missing persons have lost trust in the commission, calling on the government to revamp it with statutory powers. “The government should appoint an individual who has the courage and strength to take practical measures to end enforced disappearances and hold powerful state institutions involved in the extra-constitutional practice.”
‘Replace COIED with truth and reconciliation body’
Activist Amina Masood Janjua, chairperson of the Defence of Human Rights (DHR), shared Baloch’s frustration over the commission’s inability to hold government officials accountable. She called for scrapping the commission and replacing it with a truth and reconciliation body. “We have no reason to think that a mere replacement of the head would lead to the removal of flaws in the COIED which has failed to issue production orders of missing persons or hold government officials for dead bodies of missing persons,” she told Voicepk.
Janjua took exception to the Attorney General’s remarks in the Supreme Court about bringing in legislation for preventing enforced disappearances in the country. “How come the government can bring legislation without consulting stakeholders victims, their families, and activists,” she said. She noted that previous attempts at legislation against enforced disappearances had led to bills going missing in the National Assembly and the Senate.
International criticism
The International Commission of Jurists (ICJ) has been one of the most vocal critics of the COIED. In its 2020 briefing paper, the ICJ highlighted the commission’s failure to address impunity and provide justice for victims and their families. The report outlined several structural and operational flaws, including a lack of independence and impartiality; absence of a transparent selection process for commissioners; inadequate victim and witness protection mechanisms; a flawed definition of enforced disappearance; limited scope of inquiry; failure to hold perpetrators accountable, and no public reporting on its activities.
Ian Seiderman, ICJ’s Legal and Policy Director, stated, “A commission that does not address impunity, nor facilitate justice for victims and their families, can certainly not be considered effective.”
In 2022, Chief Justice of the Islamabad High Court, Athar Minallah, referred to the commission as a liability that had failed to justify its existence. Despite such damning assessments, the government repeatedly extended the tenure of Justice Javed Iqbal, ignoring calls for reform from national and international stakeholders.
Enforced disappearances remain a grave human rights violation under international law. States have an obligation to thoroughly and impartially investigate such cases, hold perpetrators accountable, and provide reparations to victims. However, in Pakistan, hundreds, if not thousands, of individuals remain missing following their apparent arrest or abduction, often with the tacit or explicit complicity of state actors. The United Nations Working Group on Enforced Disappearances has described the situation as a “culture of entrenched impunity.”
While the COIED has traced the whereabouts of some missing persons, it has not made any significant progress in fixing responsibility or prosecuting those involved in enforced disappearances. Activists and legal experts argue that this lack of accountability undermines the rule of law and perpetuates a sense of injustice among victims’ families. The ICJ has urged the government to discontinue the COIED and establish a new statutory commission that adheres to international standards. Meaningful consultations with victims’ groups, human rights organizations, and other stakeholders are essential to design a mechanism that genuinely addresses the issue of enforced disappearances. According to activists, the COIED risks continuing its legacy of ineffectiveness if its structural and operational flaws are not addressed first.