October 22, 2024
Staff Report
LAHORE
The International Commission of Jurists (ICJ) has condemned Pakistan’s newly passed 26th Constitutional Amendment, terming it a blow to judicial independence, the rule of law, and human rights.
The amendment, passed by the Senate and National Assembly on October 20 and 21, late at night, expands political influence over judicial appointments and administration.
One major change is the process for appointing the Chief Justice of Pakistan. A 12-member parliamentary committee will now appoint the country’s top judge with at least a two-thirds majority vote. Previously, the most senior judge of the Supreme Court automatically became the Chief Justice.
“These changes bring an extraordinary level of political influence over the process of judicial appointments and the judiciary’s own administration,” said Santiago Canton, ICJ’s Secretary General. He added that the amendments erode the judiciary’s ability to function independently and effectively as a check on excesses by other branches of the state, and to protect human rights.
“These changes bring an extraordinary level of political influence over the process of judicial appointments and the judiciary’s own administration,” said Santiago Canton, @ICJ_org's Secretary General.
Read more 🔗 https://t.co/C6JYfSjuqm
— ICJ – Asia and the Pacific (@ICJ_Asia) October 21, 2024
Key provisions of the amendment also include changes to the Judicial Commission of Pakistan (JCP), the body responsible for nominating judges. Before the 26th Constitutional Amendment, the JCP comprised a majority of judges.
However, the JCP now includes members of Parliament, and one woman or non-Muslim member, to be nominated by the Speaker of the National Assembly, reducing the number of judges on the commission. The ICJ argued that this change opens the door to political interference.
“These changes in the JCP’s composition allow for direct political influence and reduce the JCP’s judicial members to a minority,” the ICJ said.
The amendment also gives the JCP the power to nominate “constitutional benches” within the Supreme Court and High Courts, raising concerns about impartiality in cases involving constitutional interpretation and human rights.
“There is serious concern that these JCP-appointed benches will not be independent and impartial,” the ICJ warned.
Additionally, the ICJ raised concerns over changes to the process for removing judges from the superior judiciary. The amendments empower the Supreme Judicial Council (SJC)—the body responsible for recommending judge removals—to dismiss judges of the Supreme Court and High Courts for “inefficiency.” Previously, the grounds for removal were limited to incapacity or misconduct.
“These amendments directly violate Article 14 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR), which guarantees the right to equality before courts and tribunals and to a fair, public hearing by a competent, independent, and impartial tribunal,” the ICJ said. “Article 10A of Pakistan’s Constitution also recognizes the right to a fair trial.”
While the ICJ acknowledged the need for some reforms to make the judicial system more efficient and transparent, Canton emphasized that these amendments undermine fundamental democratic principles.
“These amendments are an attempt to subjugate the judiciary and bring it under executive control, betraying the rule of law, separation of powers, and judicial independence,” he added.
