June 7, 2024
By Ahmed Saeed
LAHORE:
The press organisations have expressed unease over the issuance of show-cause notices by the Supreme Court of Pakistan to 34 TV channels for broadcasting the alleged anti-judiciary press conference by parliamentarians.
Supreme Court (SC) issued notices to the TV channels while hearing the contempt case initiated against Senator Faisal Vawda and MQM MNA Mustafa Kamal for allegedly holding contemptuous press conferences against judges of the Supreme Court and the Islamabad High Court (IHC).
“The broadcast of the press conferences on the said channels prima facie appears to constitute contempt. Therefore, let notices be issued to all the said channels, to be served through PEMRA, and they are called upon to submit their explanations/replies within two weeks as to why they should not be proceeded against for contempt of Court,” SC order states.
Ayaz Khan, senior Vice President of the Association of Electronic Media Editors and News Directors (AEMEND), said that it is unprecedented that notices have been issued to such a large number of channels. “The question here is why should the media not air the press conference of a senator? If the senator is in contempt, then the question should only be asked from that senator. I don’t see any reason why the channels were given notices in this matter.”
Absar Alam, a senior journalist and former Chairman of the Pakistan Electronic Media Regulatory Authority (Pemra), wonders why the media has been issued notices, as “it will create more confusion in the media.”
“This will surely send a negative message to the channels, and mount pressure on them,” he says.
He adds, “The issue is that the powerful groups have reduced channels as footballs, kicking them here and there to fulfill their agendas. In such a scenario, it will curtail media freedom.”
SC has already started contempt proceedings against Vawda and Kamal, with the latter having thrown himself at the mercy of the court, seeking forgiveness. Senator Vawda, however, sought time from the court for further contemplation.
Alam expressed the view that the SC should have moved against the TV channels only if the contempt by the two lawmakers had been proved – “Otherwise, the TV channels will block all the press conferences and will never broadcast any live press conferences.”
Senior lawyer and former Vice Chairman of the Pakistan Bar Council, Hassan Raza Pasha, is confident hopes that the SC will not pass strict orders against channels in this matter. “Chief Justice Qazi Faez Isa supports a free press, and will surely not pass any adverse orders against the media. Instead, he is likely to pass future guidelines to the media,” he adds.